just remember that when you posted pictures of the greddy type s ya had a topmount? i think anyway.
when i went to fit it i noticed in my tmic pipe (cusco jobby) the hole from the main pipe to the dump pipe was restricted, and i ended up with the same noise no matter what, tried it on a front mount with the dv by nearer the throttle body and it sounded lovely
edit ignore that, it was a different person i was thinking of with the greddy type s.
either way still the same situ, i have fitted 3 dump valves, hks, blitz and a greddy type s, all sounded basically the same, and was caused by a restriction,