Worth noting that with a plate type diff, you need to use the correct oil with friction modifiers to minimise clunking and if you buy second hand you run the risk of;
1. Getting one that's shagged and needs a rebuild
2. If it wasn't run/broken in correctly then small particles of metal can get in between the plates and cause them to go slightly off axis, coupled with the fact that the faces of all the plates won't be perfectly flat and perpendicular when new mean that if the correct procedure isn't followed then, then the diff will probably always clunk.
If you buy new and run it in properly non of that should occur.
Also a plate type will need regular oil changes to prevent the above.
My advice if buying any type of diff is to think about what you want it to do, as different types do different things to the car on the road. It's not just a matter of one type being better than the other.