Well i have only two things to compare having a meshed inlet to, the stock efi pipe / airbox combo and no filter over the inlet at all. In comparison to the stock airbox the car drove much better, it made a noticeable difference in performance. However in comparison with no filter i noticed no difference, i can't envisage a paper filter flowing better than no filter, not the most scientific of tests i know. I would be interested to see the difference between a paper filter and a meshed inlet if a proper scientific test was carried out, unfortunately i'm doing the wrong degree.
I have seen you have this debate with other members but i have yet to decide who is right without solid proof.